Once upon a time, an illustrious student applied to Harvard claiming to be from one of the best prep schools and one of the best colleges in the country with amazing scores and great grades. He lied.
While this has been widely reported in the media, most of the reports have been very easy on Harvard’s admission office. One of the experts in the field went so far as to say that, given the thousands of applications schools receive, documents just can’t be verified.
Poor Harvard. So many applications, so little time.
One the one hand, that’s just plain silly. This guy faked transcripts. Maybe I can see, given the right computers and blah blah, slipping that document past someone. If, however, a school has at least a couple of nickels to rub together (and who has more nickels than Harvard?!), perhaps they could invest in a nice document imaging system. Nearly every reputable college in the country (and the applicant was claiming to have attended MIT) uses really fancy transcript paper that shows all kinds of stuff when you scan the document. This makes copying or scanning the document challenging – and lets us know it’s a real document. Did the student go so far as to obtain that paper? If not, how the heck did he get it past the office?
Let’s, however, give poor over-worked Harvard (cue violins) the benefit of the doubt on the transcripts. They also accepted the applicant’s fraudulent SAT scores. I can’t speak for every institution, but Mason downloads scores directly from CollegeBoard. We go back and verify with CB data most that come in from the high school or the student directly.
On the other hand, since the student was transferring, maybe the Harvard admissions office wasn’t that worried about his scores (which makes sense), and since those scores were REALLY GOOD (and whose wouldn’t be, if we were picking them ourselves), why check further? Fine – I’ll consider letting Harvard off the hook.
Let’s move on to how this exposes the DIRTY SECRET OF COLLEGE ADMISSIONS.
Wait for it.
The even dirtier secret is – admissions offices probably don’t catch most of those liars. Applicants submit all kinds of recommendation letters, lists of extra-curriculars, and claims of awards and achievements. For the most part, colleges make no effort to verify the authenticity of these submissions. There are rare exceptions. With the internet so readily accessible, an applicant claiming to have appeared on “Big Brother” and “America’s Got Talent” is easily referenced. The applicant, however, falsely claiming to have won the “East Podunk Service Commitment to Youth that are Far Less Lucky Award” is unlikely to get caught.
In fairness, as I’ve mentioned elsewhere, these factors are FAR less important to admission decisions than academic records (and, the recent Harvard debacle aside, false academic records are much harder to slip past our processes). I should also note, for all those tempted by the knowledge of admissions offices lax verification, that the penalty for getting caught is generally steep. Most admissions offices, if they believe that any – ANY – part of the application has been falsified, will deny the applicant. You won’t get a reason – just the denial.
So we’re not that good at catching you, but we have a REALLY strong disincentive. How many of you think that works? Be seeing you.
Filed under: Applications, College Admissions, Education, Life, University | Tagged: admission, Admissions, application, Applications, College, College Admissions, College Board, College Search, College Search Process, Education, essay, Family, George Mason University, GPA, Grades, Harvard, High School, Life, Parents, Recommendations, SAT, tests, Transfer Students, University |